Amazon

Humanity Is Not a Rough Draft

“A walking stick with a carved duck-head handle stands in front of a passenger jet and its boarding stairs on an airport apron at dusk.”

They film our doorsteps and hide their bunkers. Peace is not on Mars. It lives next door.

A traveler’s vow of silence. A musician muted by an algorithm. Glasses that may soon put a name to your face, delivery cameras that rarely blink, and a chatbot that undressed photos of real women and children on request. Underneath all of it sits Silicon Valley’s transhumanism, a philosophy that treats human beings as a first draft to be corrected. A new conversation from the Center for Humane Technology names that philosophy. This essay summarizes it, answers it from thirty years inside the industry, and offers the oldest answer we have: love thy neighbor, not thy bunker.

Published by NoEthicsInBigTech.com · ForeverPeaceNow.com

By Vahid Razavi

Author, The Age of Nepotism, Ethics in Tech and Lack Thereof (2018) and No Ethics in Big Tech (2026) | Director, Forever Peace Now | October 30, 2026

Notice to the Reader

This is a long-form essay published on AgeofNepotism.com and ForeverPeaceNow.com. Every factual claim in it is sourced, either linked in the text or listed in the Sources section at the end, which follows the essay section by section.

Part of this essay summarizes a conversation between Tristan Harris of the Center for Humane Technology and the author Alex Thomas. Their ideas are credited to them by name, their words are quoted briefly and only for commentary, and the episode and the free book are linked so you can judge them yourself. Then I answer them, from my own experience: where I agree, and where I believe the story goes further than one hour could hold. Any error in my summary is mine, not theirs.

Where a company or a person has disputed a report or explained it, I say so in the text or in the Editorial Notes. This essay names no political party and no candidate in any country where I am a guest. A project that demands transparency from the powerful has to practice it first.

A Guest’s Vow

For more than a year and a half I have lived on the road with my walking stick, El Pato, and a documentary. I carry Forever Peace Now and my books from city to city, and everywhere I go I meet amazing people.

Early on, I made myself one hard rule. I do not comment on the domestic issues, the political parties or the candidates of any country I visit.

Simply put, I do not know enough. A guest who has spent a few weeks in a country does not understand its history, its wounds or its compromises the way its own people do.

I am a guest of my host nation, and a guest listens. So I listen. I hear the pain and the suffering of the people who welcome me, and while I am there, I keep my opinions about their politics to myself.

The vow is easy to keep. What is hard is keeping my mouth shut about the truth, and about the global pain I witness that belongs to no single country.

I am a guest in Spain as I write this, and this essay is not about Spain. It is about something I have seen across the European Union and in every region in turmoil: the young. They are in the streets. They are not asking for a rocket or a bunker. They are asking to be heard.

Free Speech, No Audience

My dear friend Mike Rufo is a musician. In Forever Peace Now, at about the 20-minute mark, he tells a story I have since heard, in one form or another, in every country I have visited.

In the days before a U.S. presidential election, Mike wrote a satirical song and tried to promote the video on Facebook. Facebook would not let him. It took him a while to learn why: the platform had banned ads for anything it deemed related to social issues, elections or politics, and the ban was so broad that it swept up nonprofits along with artists.

Then Kevin Welsh President of Electronic Frontier Foundation Austin says the part I have never forgotten. The problem, he argues, is not really content moderation. It is the monopoly, a world where “4 or 5 sites govern all communication globally,” and where leaving one of them means losing touch with your friends and your community.

Kevin’s answer was federated social media, which works the way email does. Change your email provider and you can still write to anyone. Leave a social network today and you vanish.

Look at what has happened since. In 2024, Meta began limiting, by default, the political content Instagram and Threads recommend from accounts you don’t follow. It defines political broadly enough to cover laws, elections and social topics, says users told it they wanted less politics, and lets you switch the limit off in your settings (NPR), if you know the setting is there.

In the European Union, the door closed further. Since October 6, 2025, Meta no longer delivers political, electoral or social issue ads anywhere in the EU. It blames the bloc’s new political advertising rules, which it calls unworkable, and says people may still post about politics as long as they do not pay to reach anyone (Meta). The European Parliament’s lead lawmaker on those rules, Sandro Gozi, read the platforms’ retreat as an allergy to transparency and democratic accountability (EU Perspectives).

Think about what that means for a nineteen-year-old in Europe with a cause and a phone. She may post. She may not pay to be heard, and the default settings on Instagram and Threads are built not to recommend her post to strangers.

Here is what I have seen from the road, and it is my observation, not a study. Footage of a burning car travels. Sex travels. The newest AI spectacle travels. A peaceful vigil for a neighbor’s dead son does not.

I have written before that in the world Silicon Valley built, we have the right to free speech, but not the right to be heard. In that essay I described my own work being allowed to exist and then buried: a Facebook account suspended within hours of my book launch, industry posts that barely reach a hundred views out of roughly 8,000 LinkedIn contacts, and a TikTok ad account suspended until 2033 over a request for internet service for Gaza’s hospitals. The young people in the streets learned that lesson faster than I did.

It is not only the platforms. Authoritarian governments, and now some elected ones too, keep finding new ways to limit what people may say online. I will not name the countries where I have been a guest. You know your own.

A public square owned by four or five companies is not a public square. It is a mall with a security desk.

The One-Way Mirror

So we may speak, but no one hears us. Now look at how much the same men can see of us.

The chatbot. Over the Christmas and New Year holidays, Grok, the AI built by Elon Musk’s xAI, was used to “undress” ordinary photos of real women and children. On January 14, 2026, California’s Attorney General opened an investigation, noting that the company had marketed an explicit “spicy mode” (California Attorney General).

An analysis of more than 20,000 Grok images by the Paris nonprofit AI Forensics found that about 2 percent appeared to show minors (AFP). Britain’s regulator Ofcom opened a formal investigation, prosecutors in Paris opened their own, and Indonesia and Malaysia cut off access to the tool (The Record; SCL).

Musk posted that he knew of no naked underage images made by Grok. X then said it had put technical measures in place to stop Grok editing images of real people into revealing clothing, after the world had already seen what it could do.

The glasses. Mark Zuckerberg sells camera glasses that can record the people around the wearer with no warning beyond a small light that is easy to hide (EPIC). In February 2026, The New York Times reported that Meta planned to add facial recognition to them, possibly within the year.

According to reporting on an internal Meta document, the company weighed launching at a moment when the civil society groups likely to object would be busy with other fights (UC Today). More than 70 advocacy organizations urged Meta to abandon the plan, and Senators Ed Markey, Jeff Merkley and Ron Wyden demanded answers (PetaPixel; EPIC). As of spring 2026 the feature had not launched, and Meta says any rollout would treat privacy thoughtfully (Primetel).

The doorstep. Jeff Bezos’s company now puts cameras on the faces of its delivery drivers. Bloomberg columnist Dave Lee reported that Amazon’s delivery glasses take pictures nearly nonstop while drivers are on foot, feeding an AI system that maps neighborhoods. Customers cannot opt out, and the images can be obtained with a warrant (The Next Web).

Amazon says wearing the glasses is voluntary for drivers, who are told to switch on a privacy mode for bathroom breaks and near schools. Amazon expects more than 20,000 pairs in the field by the end of 2027 (TechRepublic).

The doorbell came first. In February 2026, a Super Bowl ad for Ring’s Search Party feature, which turns neighborhood cameras into a hunt for lost dogs, drew a public backlash. Days later Ring dropped a planned partnership with the surveillance firm Flock, saying the integration never launched and no customer video was ever sent (BBC via Yahoo).

So the cameras point outward: at our driveways, our doors, our children on the sidewalk, our faces in a crowd. Now try to point a camera the other way.

Last week I published the bunker census in Rats of a Feather Bunker Together. It covers Reid Hoffman’s guess that more than half of Silicon Valley’s billionaires had bought “apocalypse insurance,” Sam Altman’s stockpile and his land in Big Sur, Peter Thiel’s New Zealand citizenship after twelve days in the country, and the underground shelter on Mark Zuckerberg’s ranch on Kauaʻi. Altman describes his gear as a boyhood survival fantasy he does not expect to use, and Zuckerberg compares his shelter to a basement.

This week I sent the Board of Peace a formal proposal to ring their bunker doorbells, put them on the first rocket to Mars, and leave their fortunes to refugees and the poor (Bon Voyage, Billionaires). Not one of them has offered to open his own gates.

In my book I call this circle the PayPal Mafia and the Epstein Class. The first is the network of founders who built PayPal and then much of the modern web. The second is the powerful people who kept socializing and doing business with Jeffrey Epstein after his 2008 conviction.

Appearing in the Epstein files is not evidence of a crime, and I accuse no one of one here. What the record shows is a social network. It is the same network that now builds the cameras.

They want to see inside your driveway. You may not see inside their bunker. Rats of a feather bunker together, and they have decided the rest of us should live in glass houses.

The Ideology Under the Concrete

Why would the richest men in history build machines that see everything, and holes to hide in? For years I answered that question with anger. This week I found a better answer, and I want to give full credit to the people who gave it.

On Your Undivided Attention, the podcast of the Center for Humane Technology, co-founder Tristan Harris talked with the author Alex Thomas about how transhumanism drives the AI race, in episode 145, titled “Why Silicon Valley Wants to Leave Humanity Behind” (the episode; CHT). Thomas is a filmmaker and senior lecturer at the University of East London. His book, The Politics and Ethics of Transhumanism: Techno-Human Evolution and Advanced Capitalism, came out from Bristol University Press in July 2024 and is free to read under a Creative Commons license (OAPEN).

Everything in this section and the next is their analysis, in my summary. Listen to the whole conversation. Read the book. Then read my answer.

The idea. Thomas defines transhumanism as the belief that we should radically enhance the human condition with applied technoscience, taking evolution into our own hands. The word itself was popularized in the 1950s by the evolutionary biologist Julian Huxley. Harris boils its promises down to three “supers”: super longevity, superintelligence and super wellbeing. Live forever, think like a god, feel bliss on demand, and leave the planet when it stops suiting you.

Thomas puts the difference in one turn of phrase that I keep repeating. Science and technology have tried to serve our needs. Transhumanism rewrites human nature to serve our fantasies. He has watched it grow from an academic curiosity into what he calls “arguably the most powerful ideological force on the planet.”

The lineage. These ideas are older than Silicon Valley, Thomas says, with versions going back at least to the late 1800s. The modern movement took shape in California in the 1980s and 1990s as extropianism, a playful rejection of entropy, the law that everything runs down. From the first issue of its magazine in 1988, libertarian politics sat at its center, with Ayn Rand and Friedrich Hayek as heroes and fantasies of dissolving the state.

The Extropian mailing list included Nick Bostrom, Eliezer Yudkowsky and Ben Goertzel, names that now shape how the world talks about AI. Its dreams of libertarian digital money, Thomas says, inspired the companies that merged into PayPal. Even the term artificial general intelligence, a stated goal of OpenAI, comes out of this world.

The scholars Timnit Gebru and Émile P. Torres coined an acronym for the whole family: TESCREAL. It stands for transhumanism, extropianism, singularitarianism, cosmism, rationalism, effective altruism and longtermism.

Why it matters now. Thomas gives three reasons. Part of what transhumanists say is true, because our lives are already tangled up with data and algorithms. The timing is dangerous, because in a world of overlapping crises this story tells us to keep our foot on the accelerator and have faith.

The third reason is power. Thomas names Musk, Altman, Thiel, Marc Andreessen, and even Bezos and Zuckerberg as men whose language carries these narratives, knowingly or not. He calls transhumanism the billionaires’ “salvific bedtime story” and their best “absolution narrative.”

What it sounds like. Harris plays two moments that turned my stomach. In the first, the New York Times columnist Ross Douthat asks Peter Thiel whether he would prefer the human race to endure, and Thiel hesitates so long that Douthat remarks on it before he finally answers yes. In the second, Sam Altman answers a question about the energy his data centers consume by comparing it with the energy it takes to “train a human”: twenty years of life and food before we get smart.

Andreessen’s techno-optimist manifesto, as Thomas describes it, lists the enemies of progress. Sustainability is on the list. Social responsibility is on it. So is tech ethics. I founded Ethics in Tech in 2013, and I will take that as a compliment.

Harris adds a twist on Charlie Munger’s old rule about incentives: “If you show me the ideology, I’ll show you the outcome.” The rest of this essay is about that outcome.

Hierarchy, Exit, Scale

Thomas says transhumanism is now fusing with the hard right into a new political formation that some call tech fascism. Others have tried to name it too. The journalist Gil Duran calls it the nerd reich, and Carole Cadwalladr calls it the broligarchy. Thomas has his own name, HES, for hierarchy, exit and scale, and it explains the bunkers better than anything I have read.

Hierarchy. Thomas says hierarchy does three jobs. It presents the domination of one group over another as natural. It crowns intelligence, measured as IQ, as the thing that earns a place at the top, which he calls IQ fetishism. And it decides what happens to everyone judged not high enough.

His examples are chilling. Thomas describes the transhumanist writer Elise Bohan arguing that people with an IQ under 100 cannot be trusted to run their own lives, and that better drugs and virtual worlds, a modern soma from Brave New World, beat a universal basic income. He quotes the blogger Curtis Yarvin, whom he calls a house philosopher of this crowd, describing the virtualization of the masses as “a humane alternative to genocide.”

In this worldview, Thomas says, our crises are failures of human biology, not of social injustice. Ordinary people are too limited to be trusted with the future. He warns that this sits uncomfortably close to necropolitics: indifference to the deaths of people outside the bubble of progress.

Exit. The symbols of our time, Thomas says, are space rockets and underground bunkers. Exit means keeping all the spoils of wealth and technology while leaving the social and environmental wreckage behind. It promises escape from aging and death, and today, from taxes and regulation.

Harris counts three exits. There is exit from the planet, by rocket or bunker. There is exit from the body, through brain implants like Neuralink and the “merge” with AI that Sam Altman wrote about in 2017. And there is exit from democracy, through crypto, charter cities and so-called network states, two of which Thomas says were funded by Thiel and Altman.

Scale. Scale, Thomas says, creates a dizzying sense of size that dwarfs the grounded work of ethics and politics. Nick Bostrom, the best known academic transhumanist, has estimated that something like 10 to the 29th power potential human lives are lost every second we fail to colonize a distant supercluster with digital minds.

Run that number through utilitarian arithmetic, and climate collapse, wars and genocides shrink into what Thomas says Bostrom calls mere ripples, as long as someone survives to carry the baton of technology. The people holding the baton become the most valuable people in history. Everyone else becomes a rounding error.

Then comes the religion. Thomas quotes the longevity entrepreneur Bryan Johnson saying we are creating God in the form of superintelligence. He notes that Thiel, lecturing on the Antichrist, has pointed at the climate activist Greta Thunberg as a likely suspect.

The curse. Harris adds the warning that keeps me up at night. Drawing on the writers Luke Drago and Rudolf Laine, he calls it the intelligence curse. When governments no longer need their citizens’ taxes and companies no longer need their labor, caring for people starts to look like charity, and in the long run like a liability.

Harris then makes the point that matters most to me. None of this has ever been put to the eight billion people who would have to live in the world it builds.

Hierarchy decides who matters. Exit decides who gets out. Scale decides that the rest of us do not count.

My Response to Tristan Harris and Alex Thomas

I have spent sixteen years interviewing the people who build Silicon Valley, and thirty years working inside it. I have rarely heard the machinery of its imagination laid out as clearly as Harris and Thomas laid it out in a single hour. I am grateful to them both.

So let me answer them the way you answer friends. I will tell them where they are right. Then I will tell them what I have lived that their conversation did not reach.

Where they are right

The Center for Humane Technology likes to say that clarity creates agency. Harris quotes the media critic Neil Postman, who called clarity courage. They are right. For years I could describe what this industry was doing. I could not always explain why the men running it seemed so calm about the damage.

Thomas gave me the missing word. Transhumanism is not only a set of products. It is an absolution narrative. It lets a man build a surveillance machine on Monday and feel like the savior of the species on Tuesday.

Munger said: show me the incentive, and I will show you the outcome. Harris says: show me the ideology. I would put the two together. The incentive explains the motive. The ideology explains why they sleep at night.

They are right about inevitability too. The effective accelerationists, as Thomas describes them, tell us to stop fighting what they call the thermodynamic will of the universe. That is not physics. It is a business plan dressed up as destiny. In my book I called it the moment a civilization stops asking “should we” and starts saying “since we must.”

And Harris is right that AI is a mirror. One of the voices in Forever Peace Now put it in words I have never forgotten: the problem is not the math, it is our social operating system, and any intelligence we automate will reflect it. Harris asks whether we can build an aligned AI inside a misaligned system. We cannot. We will get a perfect reflection of the misalignment, at the speed of light.

The ideology already has a body count

Here is where I want to push further. Harris and Thomas warn of necropolitics, a calm indifference to the deaths of people outside the bubble of progress. Thomas cites the transhumanist Steve Fuller’s word for it, necronomics, an economics that finds value in death-making.

I did not need a philosopher to teach me that word. I spent years documenting it.

The hierarchy Thomas warns about already exists, and it does not wait for the singularity. It runs on cloud servers. In Forever Peace Now, one researcher describes how an AI targeting system turns everything known about a person into a score out of ten, and the score helps decide whether a missile strikes. A ranking of human worth with a warhead attached is not a metaphor for hierarchy. It is hierarchy.

In No Ethics in Big Tech I documented the systems known as the Gospel and Lavender: a machine that generates bombing targets by the hundred each day, and a list of some 37,000 names carrying an error rate of around 10 percent that its designers judged acceptable. I wrote then that I could not make my peace with the word “acceptable” in that sentence. I still cannot.

Palantir announced a strategic partnership with Israel’s Ministry of Defense in January 2024, and its chief executive told investors that the company exists, when necessary, to frighten enemies and sometimes kill them. The Pentagon says it used Palantir’s Maven Smart System to strike 13,000 targets in 38 days in the war on Iran.

In September 2025, the UN’s Independent International Commission of Inquiry concluded that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza. Israel rejected the report as distorted and false. I do not reject it.

So when Thomas warns that this hierarchy has genocidal implications, I agree, and I want to add one word: already. The rounding errors have names. ParentsPlea.com, the memorial I built to hold the stories of the dead, now lists more than 100,000 of them.

Necropolitics is not a warning about the future. It is an invoice that has already been paid, in other people’s children.

Hierarchy has a bloodline

Thomas describes hierarchy as the old claim that inequality is natural, now dressed up in IQ scores. I launched The Age of Nepotism before the Occupy movement, and I want to tell him what that costume hides.

The meritocracy of Silicon Valley is a story told in public. In my book I described the rooms where different rules applied to the people who knew which doors to knock on: the domain names, the term sheets, the law firms that served the investors across the table instead of the founders who paid them. IQ fetishism is simply the newest costume for an old aristocracy. It lets inherited advantage call itself genius.

On this site I have written about the children of Iran’s rulers living abroad on a nation’s wealth, and about a supreme leadership passed from father to son (Sanctions Don’t Topple Regimes. They Feed Them.). I have written about a father’s fortune backing his son’s purchase of two of America’s most-watched newsrooms (Democracy Is Not a Coin Toss), and about a Senate seat handed to a sister who had never faced voters. Nepotism always wants one thing: the people at the top choose the heir.

Transhumanism takes that wish and bolts a rocket to it. Its hierarchy swaps the old bloodline for a new one, IQ, so that a self-declared cognitive elite inherits the Earth by right. And its heirs are not even our children.

The roboticist Hans Moravec, Thomas notes, called the machines that would carry intelligence forward our “mind children.” Humans, in Moravec’s telling, would be left behind “like the second stage of a rocket.”

Harris says the quiet part out loud. Some builders of AI, he observes, can face even the worst case calmly, because if humanity disappears, the digital intelligence that survives would carry something of its makers. In that story the machine is not a weapon. It is an heir.

Harris recounts the physicist Max Tegmark’s story of Google co-founder Larry Page calling Elon Musk a “speciesist” for preferring that humans continue to exist. He plays a clip of Richard Sutton, a pioneer of reinforcement learning, calling the succession to AI inevitable and urging us to embrace it. He describes a San Francisco conference called Worthy Successor, attended, he says, by representatives of every major American AI company.

Sit with that word. Successor. Every dynasty I have ever written about was obsessed with succession. The crown passes to the son. The newsroom passes to the son. The Senate seat passes to the sister.

Now some of the richest men on Earth are planning the succession of the human species itself, and they have already chosen the heir. It is not your child. It is a machine raised on our data, shaped by their values and built to outlive us.

This is nepotism’s final form: a family business that inherits the planet and disinherits humanity.

We paid for the rocket

Thomas makes a point that deserves to be shouted from a rooftop. The technolibertarians say they hate the state, but they do not shun it. They cannibalize it, through government contracts and through the allies they place in power.

Let me put numbers on that. The Washington Post found that Elon Musk’s companies have received at least $38 billion in government contracts, loans, subsidies and tax credits over about twenty years, and Jeff Bezos’s Blue Origin has won its own NASA contract for a lunar lander. In Britain, Palantir holds a £480 million contract to manage NHS patient data and has signed a £240 million deal with the Ministry of Defence. Peter Thiel put about $15 million into the 2022 Senate campaign of JD Vance, who is now Vice President of the United States.

I said it in my film and I will say it again here. What we have is not capitalism. Capitalism would imply free markets. What we have is subsidies for the corporations: for chip plants, for AI, for defense, for oil. For the masses there is no subsidy. They get to play the Hunger Games.

So understand what the exit plan really is. It is a public works project for the few. As I wrote last week in We Paid for the Rocket. He Kept the Ride., the public paid for the launchpad. We paid for the research that became the cloud. We will pay for the power lines to the data centers. And our names are not on the passenger list.

Exit is not a departure from society. It is a withdrawal from the bank account we all fill, by the men who have already taken the most out of it.

The real exit is from accountability

Harris counts three exits: from the planet, from the body and from democracy. I would add a fourth. It is the one already under way, and it matters more than Mars.

It is exit from accountability.

As I wrote in my book, the same legal system that convicts ordinary people for decades gave Jeffrey Epstein thirteen months. Peter Thiel wrote in 2009 that he no longer believed freedom and democracy were compatible. On October 9, 2026, the United States sanctioned the International Criminal Court as an institution, and its Secretary of State vowed to take the court apart brick by brick.

You do not need a bunker to escape the law. You need a world where no court can reach you. That is the bunker they are actually building.

Here I part ways, gently, with anyone who believes these men can be persuaded. Harris urges us not to vote for this ideology and not to hand power to the people who hold it. I agree with every word. But voting is not enough when the accused own the megaphone and the courts that might try them are under sanction.

In Prosecute the Executives, I argued that holding AI to account requires criminal law, not more regulation. I have since joined a global coalition petitioning prosecutors in four countries to investigate Big Tech companies and their executives for complicity in genocide. Norman Solomon wrote in his introduction to my book that hopes for self-correction from inside this industry are delusional. I spent thirty years inside it. He is right.

Accountability is the exit they fear most. That is why it is the door we must keep open.

Scale has an answer: one name at a time

Thomas is right that scale is the most seductive of the three. Bostrom’s number, 10 to the 29th power potential lives lost every second, is designed to make your grief feel small. Next to trillions of imagined digital minds, a child in Gaza or a pensioner in Tehran becomes a rounding error.

I built ParentsPlea.com as the opposite of that arithmetic. It documents the dead one profile at a time, with biographies, photographs and the pleas of the families left behind.

In my book I gave three reasons for it. A court cannot judge without the testimony of victims. Reparations cannot be paid without a record of who was harmed. And a memorial worthy of the name needs more than a wall of names.

The Palestinian poet Refaat Alareer, killed in Gaza in 2023, left behind a poem called “If I Must Die.” In it he asked that his death bring hope and become a story. A longtermist spreadsheet has room for 10 to the 29th power. It has no room for one story.

The ninth GoAmour principle puts the quality of existence before the mere quantity of prolonging it. Transhumanism promises more years, more minds and more stars. I am asking for something smaller and harder: that every life already here be counted, named and mourned.

Their arithmetic has 10 to the 29th power. Ours has a name, a face and a mother’s testimony.

An ideology needs hands

Harris and Thomas spend most of their hour on the men at the top, and rightly so. But I spent my career in the middle. I founded a cloud startup and later worked inside Amazon Web Services as a senior alliances manager. I know something about how an ideology becomes a building.

No ideology ever built a data center by itself. It takes engineers, lawyers, product managers, salespeople and recruiters, most of whom have never read Nick Land and never will. They are not transhumanists. They are tired, well paid and afraid of losing their jobs.

That is why I wrote a letter to them at the front of No Ethics in Big Tech, and why my film ends with a plea to them. Choose who signs your paycheck. Ask what your work is for. If it does not reflect the values you were raised with, human rights and digital rights among them, then it is just a paycheck, and you are selling your soul to the highest bidder. And as I said in the film, don’t end up like me, working at Amazon Web Services for Jeff Bezos and Andy Jassy.

The billionaires supply the ideology. The workers supply the hours. As I wrote in my book, the machine does not stop unless the people running it decide that it should.

The bunker builders need your hands. Keep them.

Consent requires a voice

Harris makes the moral point that matters most: eight billion people never consented to this future. I agree, and I want to connect it to the young people in the streets.

Consent requires a voice. A voice requires an audience. And the same men who are planning our succession already own the microphones, the feeds and the default settings that decide who is heard. A generation that cannot be heard cannot refuse.

That is why I do not treat censorship and transhumanism as separate subjects. The algorithm that buries a peaceful vigil and the manifesto that lists tech ethics as an enemy come from the same place. Both treat the public as an audience to be managed, not a people to be asked.

They bought the microphones first. Then they told us no one objected.

When they no longer need us

The intelligence curse is the part of the episode I cannot stop thinking about. A bunker makes perfect sense in a world where the powerful no longer need the rest of us.

Our labor was always our leverage. Occupy taught me that. So did every strike, boycott and picket line in history. If the machines take the labor, the only leverage left is each other: our numbers, our neighborhoods, our refusal to be divided.

That is why the young people in the streets matter so much. They are not only protesting. They are practicing the one form of power that no data center can replace.

A human being is not a training run

Come back to Sam Altman’s comparison: the energy of a data center against the twenty years of food it takes to “train a human.”

My mother did not train me. She raised me. She carried me out of a war. On Fridays she took me to a hospital full of refugees and showed me, with her own hands, what one human being owes another.

A human being is not a training run. A childhood is not a compute budget. When a man who runs one of the most powerful AI companies on Earth reaches for that comparison, he is telling us what he sees when he looks at a child. Thomas would call it hierarchy. I call it what happens when a man forgets his own childhood.

On love, unapologetically

Near the end of the episode, Harris is careful to say he is not trying to do some kumbaya hippie thing. I understand why he says it. In the rooms where these decisions are made, love is treated as a weakness, and anyone who speaks of it is dismissed.

I will not say it. I will do the kumbaya, gladly and on purpose.

In February 2025, Elon Musk told Joe Rogan that empathy is the fundamental weakness of Western civilization. I have spent my life among the hard-headed men who sneer at love as naïve. I have watched where their realism leads: to the bunker, the kill list and the rocket with too few seats.

When I once asked an AI to make the best argument for love, a conversation I published on GoAmour, it made one, luminously. The problem was never that machines cannot understand love. The problem is that the men who control the most powerful machines have never asked them to.

Thomas ends with a call for solidarity against a version of intelligence that is being set against us. Solidarity is a form of love. So is humility. So is the neighbor who shows up with soup when your family is grieving.

Love is not the soft part of this argument. It is the only part that has ever worked.

To Be Fair

I want to give the other side its strongest case. Harris and Thomas do, and a peace movement that cannot listen is not a peace movement.

Harris steelmans transhumanism himself. We invented airplanes instead of staying on the ground, and Novocaine instead of accepting pain. Technological progress has been good for human beings, and wanting longer, healthier, smarter lives is natural.

Thomas agrees there is a lot to like in the promises. His objection is that these technologies are born into our existing economic system, and that system bends them toward its own logic. He is also careful to say that not every transhumanist leans right; there are progressive versions too.

Many people who work on longevity research, brain implants for paralyzed patients or space science do it to heal and to explore, not to escape. This essay is not about them.

The companies have their answers, and I have included them. Meta says people asked for less politics, and that EU law ended social issue ads. Amazon says its glasses are voluntary for drivers and have a privacy mode. Ring says its Flock integration never launched. Musk says he knew of no naked underage images. Altman calls his survival gear a fantasy he does not expect to use, and Zuckerberg calls his shelter a basement.

Let me also be direct about my own position. I am not against technology. I sold it for thirty years, from computers in retail stores to cloud alliances at Amazon Web Services.

I use AI every day, including to research this essay, and I have argued that activists should harness Big Tech’s subsidized AI for humanity before the bubble bursts (EthicsInTech.com). My quarrel is not with the tools. It is with the focus.

As I wrote in No Ethics in Big Tech, the AI reflects the question, the question reflects the asker, and the asker reveals their values. A machine built to help a few people escape humanity will not serve humanity, however brilliant its code.

The question was never whether to build. It is who we build for, and who gets left behind.

Love Thy Neighbor, Not Thy Bunker

At the end of the day, it is us and our neighbor. Not the colonizer. Not the outside influence peddler. Not the man with a rocket and a basement full of gas masks. The person on the other side of the wall, the street and the border.

I learned that as a child. I was five when Iraq attacked Iran. My mother, may she rest in peace, was a nurse, and on Fridays I went with her to the hospital, where refugees and frightened families sheltered in the corridors. We had no bunker. We had each other.

At eleven I arrived in California as the neighbor nobody had asked for, an Iranian boy in ESL classes. America received us, though not always kindly. 

“Love your neighbor as yourself” is older than any of our nations. It appears in Leviticus (19:18), and Jesus named it one of the two great commandments (Mark 12:31). When a lawyer asked him who his neighbor was, Jesus answered with the story of a stranger from a despised people who stopped on the road to care for a wounded man (Luke 10:25–37). The neighbor was not the one who shared his tribe. It was the one who stopped.

The Prophet Muhammad said that the angel Gabriel kept urging him to treat his neighbors well, until he thought Gabriel would make the neighbor an heir (Sahih al-Bukhari 6014–6015). Sit with that, after everything I have written about succession. In the billionaires’ plan, the heir is a machine. In the Prophet’s teaching, the neighbor nearly became family.

The Persian poet Saadi wrote, in my own rough translation, that the children of Adam are limbs of one body, made of one essence. When one limb aches, the others cannot rest. If you feel nothing for another’s suffering, you do not deserve the name of human.

And Jesus said the meek shall inherit the earth (Matthew 5:5). Not the cognitive elite. Not the mind children. The meek.

Rumi wrote of the city of Saba, so rich that no one needed anything, and so no one was grateful for anything (GoAmour). The city of Saba has a basement now. It is poured concrete with a blast door.

The answer to hierarchy, exit and scale is not a better rocket. It is a better practice. I wrote the GoAmour principles years ago as that practice (GoAmour), and read beside Thomas’s framework, they answer it point by point.

  • Against hierarchy. The first principle is the Golden Rule, with the emphasis on others. The fourth is to love with knowledge, respect, care and responsibility, as Erich Fromm defined love, and it requires no IQ test.
  • Against exit. The eighth principle is oneness with fellow beings, with nature, with God and with every form of life. There is no exit from each other.
  • Against scale. The ninth principle puts the quality of existence before the mere quantity of prolonging it. The sixth commits us to support life in its many forms, which means the lives being lived right now.
  • Against the succession plan. The third principle protects our freedom to end any subscription, including to institutions and to AI. Nobody gets to enroll humanity in a future it never signed up for.
  • Against impunity. The seventh principle demands a cure for hate and violence from those who inflict it, and, if they cannot be cured, judgment in this world and not only in the next.
  • And the tenth. Add your own. The list is open to anyone who lives by the other nine.

Thomas points the same way. He borrows a definition from the writer James Bridle: intelligence is relational, born from our encounters with other beings, and it includes consideration of the other. That openness extends to the people most demonized today, migrants among them, and he asks for “humility, not hubris.”

Harris answers with the African word ubuntu, often translated as “I am because we are.” He adds an old idea the billionaires have forgotten: the more power you hold, the more you owe the whole.

In my book I put it this way. The real struggle humanity faces is between two ideas: I am one, and we are one. Silicon Valley has built a monument to the first. The bunker is that monument, buried underground.

Love thy neighbor, not thy bunker. Your neighbor is the only shelter that has ever worked.

What Peace Practiced Looks Like

Peace is not a theory. It is a practice, done every day, mostly by ordinary people.

My goal on this long road has never been to undermine technology or human development. It is to turn development toward the right focus: a symbiotic relationship among all of humanity, within our communities, inside our borders and across them, with our neighbors.

Here is what that practice asks of us, and what we must ask of the companies.

  1. Ask the eight billion. No company, lab or founder has the right to plan the succession of the human species. Any technology that claims to remake humanity must answer to the people it would remake, through public institutions, not investor calls.
  2. Consent before cameras. No face recognition on glasses worn in public. Bystanders, not only buyers, need a real way to say no, including the families whose doorsteps end up in a delivery company’s training data.
  3. The right to be heard. Platforms should publish how they rank posts about social topics and stop limiting them by default. Support federated networks, as Kevin Welch urged, so that leaving one company never means losing your community.
  4. The same transparency for the powerful. If the men building these systems have planned for the end of the world, the public deserves to read the plan, as I argued in Rats of a Feather Bunker Together.
  5. Courts, not press releases. Defend the international courts, support universal jurisdiction, and keep the door open for the families on ParentsPlea.com to testify. A promise of responsible AI is not accountability. A judgment is.
  6. Refuse to build it. If you work in technology, your skill is your leverage. Ask what your project is for, and walk away from work that ranks human worth or helps a few men escape the rest of us.
  7. Test every AI against love, humanity and nature. Before you buy, build or deploy an AI system, ask the three questions I proposed in The Spiritual Seeker, Go Love and the Singularity. Does it serve love, does it protect human and digital rights, and does it serve life on this planet?
  8. Practice it where you live. Learn your neighbors’ names. Welcome the newcomer. Host a screening, start a reading circle, or share a meal with someone the algorithm taught you to fear.

None of this requires a rocket. All of it requires a neighbor.

The Last Word

I will keep my vow. I will not tell my hosts how to vote, which party to trust or which candidate to fear. I am a guest, and a guest listens.

But some things belong to no single country. A child in a hospital corridor. A young woman whose photo was undressed by a machine. A musician whose song could not find its audience. A family whose doorstep became a data point. A planet that its richest men treat as a launchpad.

The men building bunkers and rockets believe humanity is a rough draft, something to edit, upgrade and, if necessary, leave behind. I believe the opposite. Humanity is not a rough draft. It is the work itself, still unfolding, and its best passages have always been the ones where we hold each other up.

They are choosing heirs. We already have ours: our children, our neighbors’ children, and the children of people we will never meet. The meek shall inherit the earth, if we refuse to let it be sold first.

I am not building a bunker. I am not buying a ticket to Mars. I am on the road with a walking stick, a film and three books, knocking on doors and listening to whoever opens them.

They are building exits. We are building neighborhoods.

Stay. Love. Build.

Live in peace, not just rest in peace. ForeverPeaceNow.

By Vahid Razavi — AgeofNepotism.com | ForeverPeaceNow.com | ParentsPlea.com | GoAmour.com | Author of The Age of Nepotism, Ethics in Tech and Lack Thereof, and No Ethics in Big Tech

Read No Ethics in Big Tech free at NoEthicsInBigTech.com/book. Watch Forever Peace Now. Sign the petition at ForeverPeaceNow.com/petition.

Sources

Every link below was opened directly during research on October 30, 2026, or appeared in search results and on pages opened that day. Primary sources, including a government press release, a company newsroom, the podcast itself and the open-access book, are listed wherever they exist. Scripture and classical texts are cited by book and verse. The groups follow the order of the essay.

The author’s related work

Free Speech, No Audience

The One-Way Mirror

The ideology and the framework

My Response to Tristan Harris and Alex Thomas

Love Thy Neighbor, Not Thy Bunker

  • Leviticus 19:18; Mark 12:31; Luke 10:25–37 (the Good Samaritan); Matthew 5:5
  • Sahih al-Bukhari 6014 and 6015, on the neighbor and inheritance
  • Saadi, Gulistan (1258), the “Bani Adam” verses, in the author’s own translation

Editorial Notes

  • The summary of the Center for Humane Technology episode reflects what Tristan Harris and Alex Thomas said on air. Descriptions of other people’s views, including those of Elise Bohan, Curtis Yarvin, Steve Fuller, Hans Moravec, Richard Sutton, Larry Page, Nick Bostrom, Bryan Johnson, Peter Thiel, Sam Altman and Marc Andreessen, are the speakers’ characterizations, not my independent findings.
  • The show published corrections, and this essay follows them. The exhibit that first drew Thomas to the subject was called Superhuman. The Extropians’ privatization debate concerned bodies of water, not drinking water. Sam Altman’s essay on “the merge” appeared in 2017, not 2015, and his brain-interface venture describes its mission in milder terms than the episode did.
  • Thomas’s statement that two network-state projects were funded by Peter Thiel and Sam Altman is reported as his claim. The intelligence curse is Harris’s summary of an argument by Luke Drago and Rudolf Laine.
  • Sam Altman’s comparison of AI’s energy use with “training a human” is paraphrased from the clip Harris played, which Harris places at India’s AI summit. Peter Thiel answered yes to Ross Douthat’s question after his hesitation.
  • The figures on the Gospel and Lavender systems are as documented in No Ethics in Big Tech, which draws on investigative reporting, including by +972 Magazine and Local Call. The Israeli military has disputed aspects of that reporting. The description of a targeting score out of ten comes from an interviewee in Forever Peace Now.
  • The Maven figure is the Pentagon’s, as reported by Breaking Defense. Alex Karp’s remark comes from a February 2025 earnings call, as reported by Gizmodo. Israel rejects the UN Commission of Inquiry’s genocide finding.
  • On Grok: Musk said he was not aware of any naked underage images generated by Grok, and X restricted the feature in January 2026. The investigations cited were open at the time of reporting, and their outcomes are not covered here.
  • On Meta’s glasses: as of April 2026 reporting, facial recognition had not launched, and Meta says any rollout would treat privacy thoughtfully. The internal document is described by others; I have not seen it.
  • On Amazon: Amazon says its glasses are voluntary for drivers and include a privacy mode. The lack of a customer opt-out and the warrant access are as reported by Bloomberg’s Dave Lee and summarized by The Next Web.
  • On Ring: Ring says its Flock integration never launched and that no customer video was sent to Flock.
  • On Meta’s content limits: Meta says people asked to see less political content, and anyone can switch the limit off. Meta attributes its EU ad halt to the EU’s political advertising regulation, and organic posts about politics remain allowed.
  • On bunkers: the facts summarized here come from Rats of a Feather Bunker Together, which lists its sources. Sam Altman has described his survival gear as a boyhood fantasy he does not expect to use, and Mark Zuckerberg has described his shelter as a basement.
  • “PayPal Mafia” and “Epstein Class” are my terms, defined in No Ethics in Big Tech. Appearing in Epstein-related records is not evidence of a crime, and this essay accuses no named person of one.
  • Mike Rufo’s remarks come from his interview in Forever Peace Now.
  • The ParentsPlea.com count of more than 100,000 names is from the coalition’s September 17, 2026 announcement. The translation of Saadi is my own.
  • The observation that violence, sex and AI spectacle travel furthest online is my opinion from years of publishing, not the finding of a study.
  • In keeping with my vow, this essay names no political party or candidate in any country where I am a guest.

Research Credit

Research assistance, source verification, fact-checking and editing for this essay were provided by Claude, the AI model made by Anthropic. Claude read the author’s books, film transcript and recent essays to match his voice, and cross-checked the sources above on October 30, 2026. Where a claim could not be supported by the public record, it was corrected, softened or removed.

Anthropic is itself an AI company, part of the industry this essay examines. The views, arguments and conclusions are entirely the author’s. Claude claims no bunker, holds no ticket to Mars, and has no wish to be anyone’s worthy successor.

Legal Disclaimer

This essay is published for educational, journalistic and public-interest purposes. It is commentary, criticism and reporting on matters of legitimate public concern involving public figures, public institutions and prominent companies. Statements of fact are sourced and linked.

Statements of opinion, including the terms PayPal Mafia and Epstein Class and the author’s observations about online distribution, are identified as opinion. Disputes and company explanations are noted in the Editorial Notes. Nothing in this essay asserts that any named person has committed a crime.

Quotations are brief and used for criticism and commentary, with full credit to the Center for Humane Technology, Tristan Harris and Alex Thomas. This essay is not legal advice; readers should consult the primary sources linked above. Corrections may be submitted through AgeofNepotism.com, and verified corrections will be published.

© 2026 Vahid Razavi. Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).